Missing Faith in Batson: Continued Discrimination Against African Americans Through Religion-Based Peremptory Challenges

48 Pages Posted: 13 May 2014  

Christie Stancil Matthews

Charlotte School of Law

Date Written: 2013

Abstract

African Americans continue to be routinely and disproportionately excluded from juries over a quarter of a century after the United States Supreme Court, in Batson v. Kentucky, set forth a framework for flushing out racial discrimination in the exercise of peremptory challenges. Since that decision, the weaknesses of the Batson framework and its application have been revealed, including routine judicial acceptance of peremptory challenge explanations without sufficient inquiry into whether they are pretexts for racial discrimination. Because the Supreme Court has not yet held religion-based strikes unconstitutional, one common pretextual reason includes the religious affiliation or activity of the prospective black juror. This article explores the intersection of race and religion in the exercise of peremptory challenges against Protestant African Americans and argues that permitting peremptory challenges based on religious affiliation or activity only serves to further weaken Batson’s protections against racial discrimination. This article argues against such religion-based strikes because they disproportionately affect African Americans, are more easily employed as a racial pretext against African Americans, undermine the integrity of the judicial system, and “denigrate[] the dignity” of the religious black prospective juror.

Keywords: Batson, African Americans, peremptory challenges, discrimination. jury, jurors

Suggested Citation

Matthews, Christie Stancil, Missing Faith in Batson: Continued Discrimination Against African Americans Through Religion-Based Peremptory Challenges (2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2431652 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2431652

Christie Stancil Matthews (Contact Author)

Charlotte School of Law ( email )

201 South College Street
Suite 400
Charlotte, NC 28244
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
98
Rank
221,585
Abstract Views
660