Legalization Conflicts and Reliance Defenses

46 Pages Posted: 17 May 2014

See all articles by Mary D. Fan

Mary D. Fan

University of Washington School of Law

Date Written: May 15, 2014


This article addresses an open question of pressing practical import – whether people and businesses operating in the shadow of a legalization conflict have a reliance defense. A legalization conflict arises when conduct is decriminalized by one authority while remaining criminalized under another legal regime. For example, drugs, guns, undocumented immigrants, and giving legal advice or financial support for certain activities, may be both illegal and legal under conflicting regimes. People plan their lives, hopes and financial affairs around legalization laws and decrees. If people take actions now in reliance, will they face sanctions later? The question is of great import for many people and businesses, as well as the lawyers who advise them.

The article argues that reliance defenses should be available when governmental actors in charge of enforcing the criminal regime expressly acquiesce in the competing legalization. In such cases, reliance is reasonable and estoppel is required lest people or businesses be lulled by the statements of actors charged with administering the law into a snare of sanctions. Potential objections regarding privileging governmental lawlessness and the danger of giving people a normative choice of law that enables strategic gamesmanship are addressed.

Keywords: Legalization Conflicts, Rebellious Decriminalization, Reliance Defenses, Decriminalization Conflicts, Criminal Law, Defenses, Conflicts of Law, Mistake of Law, Equitable Estoppel, Administrative Law, Reasonable Reliance, Marijuana, Drugs, Firearms, Guns, Immigrants, Immigration, DACA, Deferred Actio

Suggested Citation

Fan, Mary, Legalization Conflicts and Reliance Defenses (May 15, 2014). 55 Washington University Law Review (Wash. U. St. Louis) (Forthcoming) , University of Washington, Seattle, WA Research Paper No. 2014-19 , Available at SSRN: or

Mary Fan (Contact Author)

University of Washington School of Law ( email )

William H. Gates Hall
Box 353020
Seattle, WA 98195
United States


Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics