How Do Experienced Analysts Improve Price Efficiency?

Abstract

We document that return anomalies related to management discretions are mitigated for firms followed by more experienced analysts. Nonetheless, only years of experience directly covering the firm matter while experience covering other firms is not associated with greater price efficiency. Focusing on the accrual anomaly, we then examine research and monitoring as possible channels through which experience mitigates mispricing. For firms followed by more experienced analysts, we find that forecast revisions and stock prices respond more positively to the accrual component of earnings. We further find that accrual quality is higher in firms followed by more experienced analysts, which holds after using both propensity score matching and exogenous events of brokerage closures and mergers to control for endogeneity. Collectively, our results are consistent with monitoring being the primary mechanism by which experienced analysts reduce accrual mispricing.

Keywords: Financial Analysts, Accrual Anomaly, Experience, Accrual Quality

JEL Classification: G14, G24, J24