Do Gender Quotas Pass the Test? Evidence from Academic Evaluations in Italy

Scuola Superiore Sant'Anna, LEM Working Paper Series 2014/14

28 Pages Posted: 23 Jun 2014 Last revised: 1 Sep 2014

See all articles by Manuel Bagues

Manuel Bagues

Aalto University - Department of Economics

Mauro Sylos-Labini

University of Pisa

Natalia Zinovyeva

Aalto University

Date Written: August 29, 2014

Abstract

This paper analyzes whether the presence of women in academic committees benefits female candidates. We exploit evidence from Italy, where candidates to Full and Associate Professor positions are required to qualify in a nation-wide evaluation known as Abilitazione Scientifica Nazionale. In 2012, these evaluations involved around 66,000 applications in all academic disciplines and around 900 (randomly chosen) evaluators. We estimate the causal effect of committees' gender composition exploiting the procedure of random assignment of evaluators to committees. Each additional female evaluator decreases by 2 percentage points the success rate of female candidates. The effect is similar in magnitude in evaluations for Full and Associate Professor positions, but it is only statistically significant in the later case. Information from 260,000 individual evaluations suggests that the presence of women in the committee affects the voting behavior of men. Overall, our results cast doubts on the convenience of introducing gender quotas in academia.

Keywords: gender quotas, discrimination, academic promotions

JEL Classification: J71, J16, J45

Suggested Citation

Bagues, Manuel F. and Sylos-Labini, Mauro and Zinovyeva, Natalia, Do Gender Quotas Pass the Test? Evidence from Academic Evaluations in Italy (August 29, 2014). Scuola Superiore Sant'Anna, LEM Working Paper Series 2014/14, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2457487 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2457487

Manuel F. Bagues (Contact Author)

Aalto University - Department of Economics ( email )

PO Box 1210
FI-00101 Helsinki
Finland

HOME PAGE: http://www.manuelbagues.com

Mauro Sylos-Labini

University of Pisa ( email )

Lungarno Pacinotti, 43
Pisa PI, 56126
Italy

Natalia Zinovyeva

Aalto University ( email )

P.O. Box 21210
Helsinki, 00101
Finland

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
144
Abstract Views
1,097
rank
225,321
PlumX Metrics