Risk Disclosure Preceding Negative Outcomes: The Effects of Reporting Critical Audit Matters on Judgments of Auditor Liability

Posted: 28 Aug 2014 Last revised: 5 Jan 2016

See all articles by Kelsey Brasel

Kelsey Brasel

Ball State University

Marcus Doxey

University of Alabama - Culverhouse School of Accountancy

Jonathan H. Grenier

Miami University - Department of Accountancy

Andrew Reffett

Miami University of Ohio

Date Written: January 4, 2016

Abstract

Audit practitioners, academics, and attorneys have expressed concern that disclosing critical audit matters (CAMs) will increase jurors’ auditor liability judgments when auditors fail to detect misstatements. In contrast, this study provides theory and experimental evidence that CAM disclosures, under certain conditions, reduce auditor liability judgments as jurors perceive that undetected fraudulent misstatements were more foreseeable to the plaintiff (i.e., the financial statement user suing the auditor). However, we find that CAM disclosures only reduce auditor liability for undetected misstatements that, absent CAM disclosure, are relatively difficult to foresee. Finally, CAM disclosures that are unrelated to subsequent misstatements neither increase nor reduce auditor liability judgments relative to the current regime (i.e., where CAMs are not disclosed), but reduce liability judgments relative to reporting that there were no CAMs. As such, we find that, relative to stating there were no CAMs, disclosure of any CAM (i.e., related or unrelated) provides litigation protection in cases of undetected fraud. Consequently, the CAM requirement could incentivize auditors to disclose innocuous boilerplate CAMs, thereby diluting the impact of more warranted CAM disclosures.

Keywords: Audit litigation, audit report, negligence, liability, critical audit matters, disclosure

Suggested Citation

Brasel, Kelsey and Doxey, Marcus M and Grenier, Jonathan H. and Reffett, Andrew, Risk Disclosure Preceding Negative Outcomes: The Effects of Reporting Critical Audit Matters on Judgments of Auditor Liability (January 4, 2016). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2487396 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2487396

Kelsey Brasel

Ball State University ( email )

United States

Marcus M Doxey (Contact Author)

University of Alabama - Culverhouse School of Accountancy ( email )

Tuscaloosa, AL 35487
United States

Jonathan H. Grenier

Miami University - Department of Accountancy ( email )

800 East High Street
Oxford, OH 45056
United States
513-529-2013 (Phone)

Andrew Reffett

Miami University of Ohio ( email )

Oxford, OH 45056
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
3,724
PlumX Metrics