Is Copyright Infringement a Strict Liability Tort?

79 Pages Posted: 10 Dec 2014 Last revised: 29 Apr 2017

See all articles by Patrick Russell Goold

Patrick Russell Goold

City University London, The City Law School

Date Written: December 8, 2014

Abstract

Scholars and lawmakers routinely refer to copyright infringement as a strict liability tort. The strictness of copyright liability has long been criticized as immoral, inefficient, and inconsistent with usual tort doctrine. However, this Article questions whether copyright infringement really is a strict liability tort. It advances the thesis that copyright infringement in the United States is a fault based tort, closely related to the tort of negligence. Using both doctrinal and economic methods, this Article explicates the role that fault plays in copyright infringement. Doing so not only demonstrates that copyright’s liability rule is more normatively defensible than previously appreciated, but also provides a unique tort perspective on the nature of the fair use doctrine. By seriously engaging with the analytic question of whether liability for copyright infringement is strict or not, we highlight how the fair use analysis blends and confuses two separate issues: on one hand, did the defendant cause the plaintiff harm, and, on the other, was that harm justifiable? The Article concludes that, while no substantive changes need to be made to copyright’s liability rule, judges ought to restructure the fair use analysis in order to keep these concepts distinct from one another.

Keywords: Copyright, Tort, Strict Liability, Fault Liability, Negligence, Structure, Doctrine, Economics

Suggested Citation

Goold, Patrick Russell, Is Copyright Infringement a Strict Liability Tort? (December 8, 2014). 30 Berkeley Technology Law Journal 305 (2015). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2535557

Patrick Russell Goold (Contact Author)

City University London, The City Law School ( email )

London, EC1V OHB
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
205
Abstract Views
1,563
rank
150,853
PlumX Metrics