The Politics of Legal Challenges to Pornography: Canada, Sweden, and the United States
Stockholm Studies in Politics No. 160. Ph.D. diss., Stockholm University, 2014. ISBN 9789176490471.
Posted: 20 Dec 2014 Last revised: 23 Nov 2020
Date Written: December 16, 2014
The dissertation analyzes obstacles and potential in democracies, specifically Canada, Sweden, and the United States, to address empirically documented harms of pornography effectively. Legislative and judicial challenges under different democratic and legal frameworks are compared.
Adopting a problem-driven theoretical approach, the reality of pornography’s harms is analyzed. Evidence shows its production exploits existing inequalities among persons typically drawn from other forms of prostitution who suffer multiple disadvantages, such as extreme poverty, childhood sexual abuse, and race and gender discrimination, making survival alternatives remote. Consumption is also divided by sex. A majority of young adult men consumes pornography frequently; women rarely do, usually not unless initiated by others. After consumption, studies show many normal men become substantially more sexually aggressive and increasingly trivialize and support violence against women. Vulnerable populations — including battered, raped, or prostituted women — are most harmed as a result.
The impact of attempts to address pornography’s harms on democratic rights and freedoms, specifically gender equality and speech, is explored through the case studies. Democracies are found to provide more favorable conditions for legal challenges to pornography’s harms when recognizing substantive (not formal) equality in law and when promoting representation of perspectives and interests of groups particularly injured by pornography. State-implemented approaches, such as criminal obscenity laws, are found less effective. More victim-centered and survivor-initiated civil rights approaches would be more responsive and remedial — a finding with implications for other politico-legal problems, such as global warming, that disproportionately affect disadvantaged populations traditionally largely excluded from decision-making.
* The manuscript is available on request by email to the author.
Note: © Max Waltman 2014 - Academic dissertation for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in Political Science at Stockholm University
Keywords: pornography, prostitution, trafficking, gender-based violence, sex equality, intersectionality, freedom of speech, democracy, sexual abuse, comparative politics, civil rights, comparative law, equality law, violence against women, Canada, Sweden, United States
JEL Classification: Z00
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation