What Defines an International Criminal Court? - A Critical Assessment of ‘The Involvement of the International Community’ as a Deciding Factor

Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 28, pp. 113-131

23 Pages Posted: 23 Dec 2014 Last revised: 2 Sep 2015

Date Written: July 10, 2014

Abstract

Since the post-World War II tribunals, only few scholars have attempted to draw a definitional distinction between international and national criminal courts. Remarkable exceptions include Robert Woetzel, who in 1962 categorized criminal courts according to ‘the involvement of the international community’, and Sarah Williams, who 50 years later relied on the same factor in her definitions of ‘hybrid’ and ‘internationalized’ criminal tribunals.

Through examples of rulings by the Special Court for Sierra Leone and the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia, this article will demonstrate that ‘the involvement of the international community’ is at best an unhelpful criterion when it comes to answering questions, e.g. regarding the immunity of state officials and the relevance of domestic law, that require a determination of the legal system in which the court operates.

Instead, it is argued that only criminal tribunals deriving their authority from international law should be labelled ‘international’, while the term ‘national criminal court’ should apply to tribunals set up under national law. This terminology would underline that issues concerning jurisdiction and applicable law must be settled according to each court’s constituent document and other relevant sources of law, depending on the legal system to which this document belongs.

Keywords: International courts, hybrid courts, international legal personality

Suggested Citation

Kjeldgaard-Pedersen, Astrid, What Defines an International Criminal Court? - A Critical Assessment of ‘The Involvement of the International Community’ as a Deciding Factor (July 10, 2014). Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 28, pp. 113-131. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2541663

Astrid Kjeldgaard-Pedersen (Contact Author)

University of Copenhagen - Faculty of Law ( email )

Karen Blixens Plads 16
Copenhagen, DK-2300
Denmark

HOME PAGE: http://jura.ku.dk/cilj/staff/?pure=en/persons/182315

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
49
Abstract Views
333
PlumX Metrics