Eliminating the Competency Presumption in Juvenile Delinquency Cases

49 Pages Posted: 1 May 2015

Date Written: April 1, 2015


The legal presumption used in virtually all juvenile delinquency cases in the U.S. is that all juveniles are competent to stand trial. This article calls for the elimination of that legal presumption, which is historically based on the Dusky v. United States decision and in the adult criminal justice system. The recent decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court recognize the developmental and organic brain differences between adults and juveniles. Current research demonstrates a higher frequency rate of incompetence based on intellectual deficiencies among children when compared with adults found to be not legally competent to stand trial.

By eliminating the competency presumption for juveniles in both delinquency and adult criminal proceedings, the party seeking an adjudication would be responsible for establishing that the accused juvenile is in fact, competent to stand trial. Foreign jurisdictions in Europe, Asia, Africa, and South America have long required higher thresholds — at least fourteen years of age — for holding juveniles accountable for criminal misconduct, none of them presuming that juveniles are competent to go to trial. In the alternative, by expanding the factors currently in use for determination of juvenile competency by adding developmental immaturity and mental illness, juvenile justice systems could identify the reduction of recidivist offending as the primary systemic objective.

Keywords: therapeutic jurisprudence, juvenile delinquency, criminal law, juvenile mental health, developmental immaturity, competence to stand trial, criminal procedure, litigation, juvenile law

Suggested Citation

Katner, David R., Eliminating the Competency Presumption in Juvenile Delinquency Cases (April 1, 2015). 24 Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 403 (2015), Tulane Public Law Research Paper No. 15-5, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2600603

David R. Katner (Contact Author)

Tulane University - Law School ( email )

New Orleans, LA 70118
United States
504-865-5153 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics