Taking the Costs of Consent Seriously: An Alternative Understanding of Legal Efficiency

The Journal Jurisprudence, Forthcoming

50 Pages Posted: 14 May 2015

See all articles by Daniele Bertolini

Daniele Bertolini

Toronto Metropolitan University - TRSM – Law and Business

Date Written: May 11, 2015


Most law and economics literature employs efficiency criteria that fit poorly with the structural features of the legal environment. The major limitations trace back to the analytical separation of law from its formative process, which has resulted in an almost exclusive focus on the allocative efficiency of legal entitlements and little or no attention paid to the causal relationship between the efficiency of legal rules and the efficiency of the lawmaking process. I contend that this conventional output-oriented approach is susceptible to the following criticisms: 1) it is affected by logical circularity and/or logical incompleteness; 2) it fails to provide any assurance of increased social welfare, 3) it does not account for the presence of losers, and 4) it does not account for the predictability/adaptivity trade-off associated with legal change.

Based on the foregoing considerations, this paper proposes an alternative understanding of legal efficiency. Efficiency is not an objective property of the outcome independent of the process; rather, it depends on the ability of the law-making process to embody, in a cost-effective manner, the general consensus of all the people concerned. Based on this premise, this paper proposes a methodology focused on the “process-outcome” relationship within the production of law, which I call “process efficiency analysis”. It relies on the analytical tools offered by transaction-cost economics and is grounded in the normative principles of constitutional contractarianism. In the last section of the paper, I illustrate process efficiency analysis by using an example from tort law.

Keywords: Pareto Efficiency, Wealth-Maximization, Lawmaking Process, Lawmaking Costs, Unanimity, Product Liability

JEL Classification: K00, K40

Suggested Citation

Bertolini, Daniele, Taking the Costs of Consent Seriously: An Alternative Understanding of Legal Efficiency (May 11, 2015). The Journal Jurisprudence, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2605280

Daniele Bertolini (Contact Author)

Toronto Metropolitan University - TRSM – Law and Business ( email )

350 Victoria Street
Toronto, ON M5B2K3

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics