Citizenship, Rights and Political Subjectivity in Eritrea

The Routledge Handbook of African Law: A Historical, Political, Social, and Economic Context of Law in Africa (Muna Ndulo $ Cosmas Emeziem eds, 2022)

34 Pages Posted: 27 May 2015 Last revised: 1 Feb 2022

See all articles by Kibrom Teweldebirhan

Kibrom Teweldebirhan

Harvard University, Law School

Luwam Dirar

Max Planck Foundation for International Peace and Rule of Law

Date Written: May 25, 2015

Abstract

A growing non-legal scholarship is engaging Eritrea’s contemporary. There is scant legal literature that interrogates the contemporary beyond formal discourses of law and legality, however. This article argues that formalistic and descriptive discourses, without doubting their validity, obscure Eritrea’s contemporary and limits issues that can be debated by collapsing the paradigm into binary good and bad absolutes. Eritrea contemporary, we argue, is more complex than it seems, and it has to be engaged within the existing political and legal processes that define it in order to develop coherent analytic and critique of the social and political relations they produce. Using this analytical framework, we analyze the discourse of citizenship and rights in Eritrea, which we claim is a product of a live politico-legal dynamic and explains significant part of Eritrea’s contemporary. We claim that the normative space of citizenship has been a site of ideological struggle between the state and the individual. The state constantly draws the political subjectivity of the individual by systematically mapping sphere of rights using formal and informal processes. The citizen, as such, is not a typical metaphysical subject endowed of rights but an entity that resides in an intensively contested and asymmetric ideological cosmos. The paper likewise engages in conversation with the dialect of ‘social citizenship’ – state narrative that refers to a collective and socially oriented project. We problematize the narrative on two accounts: First, the individualization of state-individual struggle that characterize the discourse contradicts the existence of a collective as a socio-juridical entity. Second, the formal and informal processes that we analyze in the paper establish highly differentiated and individualistic regime – creating tension between an individualistic and/or collectivist project. We likewise critically engage the value basis of the state’s project and highlight multiplicity of values and how these values fare towards social groups - the peasant citizenry for example. Our intention, in general, is two fold: first, to highlight methodological problems in legal scholarship related to Eritrea and second, to provoke broader debate on what discourses of citizenship, and rights might mean in the broader discourses of subjectivities across temporal and jurisdictional spaces within Eritrea and hopefully beyond.

Keywords: Eritrea, Human Rights, Subjectivity, Migration, Forced Labor, Social Citizenship, Informality, Citizneship, Public Sphere

Suggested Citation

Teweldebirhan, Kibrom and Dirar, Luwam, Citizenship, Rights and Political Subjectivity in Eritrea (May 25, 2015). The Routledge Handbook of African Law: A Historical, Political, Social, and Economic Context of Law in Africa (Muna Ndulo $ Cosmas Emeziem eds, 2022), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2610265 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2610265

Kibrom Teweldebirhan (Contact Author)

Harvard University, Law School ( email )

1563 Massachusetts Avenue
Cambridge, MA 02138
United States

Luwam Dirar

Max Planck Foundation for International Peace and Rule of Law ( email )

Bergheimer Strassse 139-151
Heidelberg, Baden-Württemberg 69124
Germany

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
344
Abstract Views
2,428
Rank
181,523
PlumX Metrics