The Responsibility of the International Legal Academic: Situating the Grammarian within the 'Invisible College'

A. Nollkaemper, W. Werner, J. d'Aspremont and T. Gazzini (eds.), International Law as a Profession (Cambridge University Press, 2016, Forthcoming).

36 Pages Posted: 10 Jun 2015

See all articles by Gleider I Hernandez

Gleider I Hernandez

Durham University; Open University of the Netherlands

Date Written: June 2, 2015

Abstract

It has been said that it is narcissistic for an international legal scholar to reflect on the role of the academic within the international legal profession. Yet international law is simultaneously constituted by and constitutes the community of international lawyers who engage with it. The relationship is ‘co-constitutive’, meaning on the one hand that it is the community of international lawyers who come to create, interpret and render operative the international law with which they engage in their professional practice; and simultaneously, that certain argumentative rules pervade the international legal discipline, generating background ideas that come to constitute, or at least structure, the professional vocabularies of all international lawyers.

This Chapter presents some reflections on the specific function of the international legal academic, and how our teachings come to structure the international law profession more generally, consider the extent to which the metaphor of a grammar common to international lawyers, which enables the creation and justifies the validity of international legal rules, constitutes the role of the international legal academic, using the metaphor of the grammarian. It will explore the international legal profession as a wider ‘community’ of practice, bound by interpretive canons or even a shared episteme rather than by a mere shared object of engagement. It will engage with so-called ‘activist’ scholarship that is mindful of its law-creative (normative) potential and seeks to take full advantage of it, acknowledge the social reality of international legal scholars being in constant engagement with practitioners, governmental officials, international judges. This Chapter will conclude with a few thoughts on how Koskenniemi’s famous call for a ‘culture of formalism’ can serve to acknowledge that the use of the international legal vocabulary is fundamentally a choice. Understanding the parameters of that choice can, above all, better understand and situate the role of the international legal scholar within the wider phenomenon of international law, and give rise to a wider ethic of responsibility on the part of international lawyers.

Keywords: Invisible college, epistemic communities, the role and function of scholarship, activism, the development of the law

Suggested Citation

Hernandez, Gleider I, The Responsibility of the International Legal Academic: Situating the Grammarian within the 'Invisible College' (June 2, 2015). A. Nollkaemper, W. Werner, J. d'Aspremont and T. Gazzini (eds.), International Law as a Profession (Cambridge University Press, 2016, Forthcoming)., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2613508

Gleider I Hernandez (Contact Author)

Durham University ( email )

Old Elvet
Mill Hill Lane
Durham, Durham DH1 3HP
United Kingdom

Open University of the Netherlands ( email )

P.O. Box 2960
Heerlen 6401DL
Netherlands

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
203
Abstract Views
1,009
rank
208,787
PlumX Metrics