Surrogacy: Is There Room for a New Liberty between the French Prohibitive Position and the English Ambivalence?

in Law and Bioethics, Current Legal Issues, M. Freeman (Ed.), Oup,2008, Vol. 11, Chapter 18, 329-357

Posted: 7 Jul 2015

See all articles by Myriam Hunter-Henin

Myriam Hunter-Henin

University College London - Faculty of Laws

Date Written: July 3, 2007

Abstract

According to one author, modern times are not an answer to our questions but another way of phrasing them (Irène Théry). The same would be true with Science. In Bioethics, Science does not provide us with legal answers but forces lawyers to rethink fundamental issues such as autonomy, welfare and parenthood. The question addressed in this paper is that of motherhood, in light of the different approaches taken to surrogacy in French and English Law. Is surrogacy just another form of medically assisted reproduction or should it attract a special legal regime?

The analogy between surrogacy and other forms of medically assisted reproduction is not fully drawn in either of the two English and French legal systems. Where English Law recognises surrogacy to some extent, French Law has altogether prohibited it. English Law also refuses to enforce a surrogacy agreement against the surrogate mother’s will whereas French Law suggests that motherhood should per se be outside the reach of contracts. Finally, where English Law legitimises and strengthens surrogacy through adoption, French judges held that adoption requests by commissioning couples amounted to a perversion of adoption rules and should be rejected in abstracto. Through Bioethics and Comparative Law, surrogacy thus offers a real challenge for legal thinking.

Keywords: surrogacy, motherhood, French Law, altruistic, commercial, autonomy

Suggested Citation

Hunter-Henin, Myriam Caroline, Surrogacy: Is There Room for a New Liberty between the French Prohibitive Position and the English Ambivalence? (July 3, 2007). in Law and Bioethics, Current Legal Issues, M. Freeman (Ed.), Oup,2008, Vol. 11, Chapter 18, 329-357. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2626600

Myriam Caroline Hunter-Henin (Contact Author)

University College London - Faculty of Laws ( email )

Gower St
London WC1E OEG, WC1E 6BT
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
114
PlumX Metrics
!

Under construction: SSRN citations will be offline until July when we will launch a brand new and improved citations service, check here for more details.

For more information