The Federalist Safeguards of Politics

71 Pages Posted: 16 Sep 2015 Last revised: 27 Apr 2016

Anthony Johnstone

University of Montana School of Law

Date Written: September 8, 2015

Abstract

The Constitution's Guarantee Clause provides “The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government.” At a time of national political division and dysfunction the Union, as well as the Republican Form of Government itself, would be better served by letting states do more, and the United States less, to fulfill this guarantee. States do and should play as important a role as the federal government in articulating and implementing the law governing state political processes, or in formal terms, their republican forms of government. This article provides a reminder that the Guarantee Clause defines state governments by the indefinite article.

The argument has four parts. Part I introduces the basic meaning of the guarantee and its evolution through the voting rights amendments. Beyond a consensus that holds our republicanism to require basic political equality, various perfectionist conceptions of a republican form of government diverge, reflecting the essential pluralism of republican governments in a federal system. Part II explains how the Supreme Court, Congress, and the Executive are now unable to articulate, let alone implement, any workable consensus on republicanism beyond a thin conception of those basic rights. Part III describes the states as the source of persistent and important distinctions in their republican forms of government, as both legal systems and political cultures that produce and are sustained by those systems. Part IV argues these distinctions in how states articulate and implement their own versions of republicanism are crucial to efforts toward reforming republicanism at the national level. Given the unsettled visions of republicanism at the national level, and the structural autonomy the states must retain at the core of our federal system, a plurality of views on republicanism among the states is not only durable but desirable.

Keywords: Guarantee Clause, Federalism, Election Law, Campaign Finance, Voting Rights, Election Administration, Representation, Political Parties

Suggested Citation

Johnstone, Anthony, The Federalist Safeguards of Politics (September 8, 2015). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2660484 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2660484

Anthony Johnstone (Contact Author)

University of Montana School of Law ( email )

Missoula, MT 59812-0002
United States

HOME PAGE: http://www.umt.edu/LAW/

Paper statistics

Downloads
73
Rank
271,572
Abstract Views
663