Telling Refugee Stories: Trauma, Credibility and the Adversarial Adjudication of Claims for Asylum

75 Pages Posted: 23 Oct 2015 Last revised: 13 Oct 2016

See all articles by Stephen Paskey

Stephen Paskey

State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo, Law School

Date Written: October 21, 2015

Abstract

When trauma survivors seek asylum in the United States, the deck is stacked against them. In most cases, the applicant’s story is the only direct evidence of the applicant’s claim, and asylum is certain to be denied if a judge finds the applicant not credible. But the stories told by trauma survivors defy cultural norms for a credible story: they are often inconsistent, vague, and both logically and chronologically disjointed. As a result, asylum may be wrongly denied. The problem is inherent in our asylum adjudication system, which subjects most applicants to an adversarial hearing.

This article uses scholarship on trauma and narrative theory to examine the challenges faced by survivors who seek asylum – and the ways a lawyer might inadvertently increase the odds of an adverse decision while drafting a declaration. The article also details original empirical research on 369 appellate cases in which immigration judges found an asylum applicant to be not credible. Overwhelmingly, judges cited inconsistencies in the applicant’s story as grounds for that conclusion – yet research among survivors proves that such discrepancies cannot be taken as evidence of falsehood. As a result, the article recommends that the adjudication of asylum claims should be removed from U.S. immigration courts, and that existing procedures be replaced with a single non-adversarial adjudication for all asylum applicants.

Keywords: asylum, refugee, credibility, trauma, narrative, adversarial adjudication

Suggested Citation

Paskey, Stephen, Telling Refugee Stories: Trauma, Credibility and the Adversarial Adjudication of Claims for Asylum (October 21, 2015). 56 Santa Clara L.R. 457 (2016). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2677317

Stephen Paskey (Contact Author)

State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo, Law School ( email )

School of Law
528 O'Brian Hall
Buffalo, NY 14260-1100
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
163
rank
177,188
Abstract Views
843
PlumX Metrics