The Constitutional Case for Independence

McHarg, Mullen, Page, and Walker (eds) The Scottish Independence Referendum: Constitutional and Political Implications, Oxford University Press, 2016, Forthcoming

41 Pages Posted: 25 Dec 2015

Date Written: December 2015

Abstract

The independence referendum arose out of an unanticipated set of political circumstances, rather than from a widely-felt and clearly-articulated sense of constitutional grievance. The referendum campaign was also conducted mainly in instrumental terms: dominated by arguments about the substantive policy consequences of independence, rather than overtly focused on Scotland’s governance arrangements. Nevertheless, this chapter argues that the instrumental case for independence was underpinned by a set of constitutional claims - about a democratic deficit; about effective governance; about the place of Scotland in the UK’s territorial constitution; and about the constitution of an independent Scotland –which in fact strongly echoed the constitutional case made for devolution a generation earlier. The chapter evaluates the strength of these arguments, arguing that there is a coherent, albeit not necessarily compelling, constitutional case to be made for independence – but one which seems likely to get stronger if post-referendum political and constitutional trends continue.

Keywords: independence, referendum, Scotland, constitution, democratic deficit, governance, devolution

Suggested Citation

McHarg, Aileen, The Constitutional Case for Independence (December 2015). McHarg, Mullen, Page, and Walker (eds) The Scottish Independence Referendum: Constitutional and Political Implications, Oxford University Press, 2016, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2707102

Aileen McHarg (Contact Author)

University of Strathclyde ( email )

16 Richmond Street
Glasgow 1XQ, Scotland G1 1XQ
United Kingdom

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
88
Abstract Views
544
rank
367,160
PlumX Metrics