Redressing the Imbalances: Rethinking the Judicial Role after R. v. R.D.S.

38 Pages Posted: 30 Jan 2016

See all articles by Richard Devlin

Richard Devlin

Dalhousie University - Schulich School of Law

Dianne Pothier

Dalhousie University - Schulich School of Law

Date Written: 1999

Abstract

The decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in R. v. R.D.S. dealt with whether a trial judge's comments, about interactions between police officers and "non-white groups", gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias in the circumstances. They strongly criticize the contrary ruling of the dissent as inappropriately drawing a false dichotomy between decisions based on evidence and decisions based on generalizations, and as improperly ignoring social context with an unwarranted confidence in the ideology of colour blindness. While more supportive of the majority's analysis, the authors also find cause for concern, with somewhat different emphasis in the nature of their concerns. Although they endorse the willingness of Justices McLachlin and L'Heureux-Dubé to take social context into account, the authors (Devlin more than Pothier) think there is insufficient cause expressed. Devlin is more impressed, and Pothier more troubled, by the greater caution regarding social context expressed by Cory and lacobucci JJ. As regards the test for a reasonable apprehension of bias, Devlin is concerned that the high threshold probability test improperly isolates judges from effective accountability, whereas Pothier supports the high threshold test so as not to render complex substantive equality analysis vulnerable to the challenge of bias. Both authors endorse the acknowledgement of the majority in the Supreme Court of Canada that colour blindness is not necessarily synonymous with impartiality.

Suggested Citation

Devlin, Richard and Pothier, Dianne, Redressing the Imbalances: Rethinking the Judicial Role after R. v. R.D.S. (1999). Ottawa Law Review, Vol. 31, No. 1, 1999, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2711747

Richard Devlin (Contact Author)

Dalhousie University - Schulich School of Law ( email )

6061 University Avenue
6061 University Ave
Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 4H9
Canada

Dianne Pothier

Dalhousie University - Schulich School of Law ( email )

6061 University Avenue
6061 University Ave
Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 4H9
Canada

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
82
Abstract Views
536
rank
405,297
PlumX Metrics