A Common Sense Understanding of Inevitable Discovery: Why Nix v. Williams Does Not Require Active Pursuit in the Application of the Inevitable Discovery Doctrine

31 Pages Posted: 15 Jan 2016 Last revised: 1 Feb 2016

See all articles by Reginald Lewis

Reginald Lewis

University of Mississippi, School of Law

Date Written: January 13, 2016

Abstract

Suppose that an officer has the requisite probable cause necessary to obtain a search warrant to seize evidence, but seizes the evidence that a search warrant would have rendered before obtaining the warrant. Should the evidence that was seized be admissible under the theory of inevitable discovery? This question's answer ultimately depends on the jurisdiction’s position on “active pursuit.” The idea of active pursuit was born out of the facts of Nix v. Williams, and has caused a divide amongst the various circuits of the United States Court of Appeals. Some have required it while others have expressly held it unnecessary.

This article is the first to draw upon the Court’s dicta from Hudson v. Michigan to advance the argument that active pursuit should not be required and that the inevitable discovery doctrine should be analyzed through a “but-for” causal analysis. But-for causation is required in order to exclude evidence, and if police misconduct is not a but-for cause of the discovery of evidence the evidence should be admitted regardless of whether there was active pursuit. This article is also the first to break down the three different approaches taken at the circuit court level to resolve this issue, and then explain why the but-for causal analysis best effectuates the Court’s holding from Nix v. Williams as well as the Court’s recent exclusionary rule jurisprudence.

Keywords: Inevitable Discovery, Active Pursuit, Hudson v. Michigan

Suggested Citation

Lewis, Reginald, A Common Sense Understanding of Inevitable Discovery: Why Nix v. Williams Does Not Require Active Pursuit in the Application of the Inevitable Discovery Doctrine (January 13, 2016). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2715196 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2715196

Reginald Lewis (Contact Author)

University of Mississippi, School of Law ( email )

MS 38677
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
53
Abstract Views
561
rank
387,103
PlumX Metrics