Solving Conflicts with International Investment Treaty Law from an EU Law Perspective: Article 351 TFEU Revisited

42 Legal Issues of Economic Integration 325 (2015)

29 Pages Posted: 3 Feb 2016

Date Written: July 12, 2015

Abstract

This article is meant to contribute to the discussion of the relationship between EU and international law. It focuses on bilateral investment agreements between EU Member States (intra-EU BITs), the majority of which will continue to have practical relevance. So how should one deal with a scenario in which the compliance with EU law (for example, state aid law) means that a Member State must breach its obligation under an intra-EU BIT (for example, by cutting returns on income from an investment protected thereunder)?

The article answers this question by critically analysing the protection granted to pre-existing international obligations of the EU Member States under so-called anterior treaties. It criticizes established case law under Article 351 TFEU as having emphasized the wrong issues, and suggests to turn the discussion back to the real questions: precisely when is there a conflict, and how far do a Member State’s duties under Article 351 (2) TFEU reach? It is argued that re-considering Article 351 TFEU will foster doctrinal clarity and flexibility in dealing with the “obligations”, and also the “rights” of the EU Member States under anterior treaties. Doctrinal clarity and flexibility will then benefit the relationship between EU and international law more generally.

Suggested Citation

von Papp, Konstanze, Solving Conflicts with International Investment Treaty Law from an EU Law Perspective: Article 351 TFEU Revisited (July 12, 2015). 42 Legal Issues of Economic Integration 325 (2015), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2726550

Konstanze Von Papp (Contact Author)

HAW Hamburg Dept Public Management ( email )

Berliner Tor 5
Hamburg, 20099
Germany

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
179
Abstract Views
626
Rank
252,685
PlumX Metrics