Too Human? Personal Relationships and Appellate Review

13 Pages Posted: 7 Mar 2016

See all articles by John M. Golden

John M. Golden

University of Texas at Austin - School of Law

Date Written: March 6, 2016

Abstract

In "If You Can’t Beat ’Em, Join ’Em? How Sitting by Designation Affects Judicial Behavior," 94 Tex. L. Rev. 451 (2016), Mark Lemley and Shawn Miller marshal evidence for a post-designation deference effect — a phenomenon whereby the stringency of appellate review is substantially affected by personal relationships between judges that form when trial judges sit by designation on the appellate court. The appellate court studied by Lemley and Miller is the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The category of legal question that they study is patent claim construction, the judicial process of determining a patent’s literal scope that lies at the center of much patent litigation. Lemley and Miller provide intriguing support for the proposition that sitting with the Federal Circuit by designation has enabled district court judges to enjoy strikingly lower reversal rates after their Federal Circuit service. Although the case for a post-designation deference effect is not watertight, Lemley and Miller’s study raises intriguing questions about the possible generality of any such effect and about the potential desirability of closer scrutiny of appellate courts’ use of visiting trial judges. At the very least, Lemley and Miller’s evidence for appellate decision making’s responsiveness to personal contacts reminds us that judges are human. Whether judges are "too human" in relevant respects and how to respond to their humanity are questions with which society will continue to grapple.

Keywords: patent, claim construction, appellate review, legal realism, visiting judges, sitting by designation

Suggested Citation

Golden, John M., Too Human? Personal Relationships and Appellate Review (March 6, 2016). 94 Tex. L. Rev. See Also 70-81 (2016), U of Texas Law, Public Law Research Paper No. 639, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2742954

John M. Golden (Contact Author)

University of Texas at Austin - School of Law ( email )

School of Law
727 East Dean Keeton Street
Austin, TX 78705
United States
(512) 232-1469 (Phone)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
24
Abstract Views
271
PlumX Metrics