Administrative Internet Censorship by Korea Communication Standards Commission

Soongsil Law Review, Vol. 33, January 2015, pp. 91-115

26 Pages Posted: 17 Mar 2016

Date Written: December 24, 2014

Abstract

Korean Communication Standards Commission is one of the few administrative bodies around the world empowered to block or delete contents on Internet like ACMA of Australia, ICTA of Turkey, etc. This paper evaluates KCSC's structure and actions and follows judicial discourse over the agency's validity. It discovers the surprising features such as the fact that its standards of review are not the lawful/unlawfulness of the contents but rather the soundness/unsoundness, "what is necessary for nurturing sound communication ethics", whose lack of clarity borders on upon unconstitutionality. Also, KCSC's decisions are not notified to the posters whose contents are taken down by KCSC, insulating its actions from any appeal or judicial review. However, both of these features are triggered by the agency's desire to take actions free from constitutional constraints through the form of corrective requests, a desire identified long ago by free speech scholars as the reason for frowning upon administrative censorship even if it takes effect post-publication. In the wake of French Constitutional Court's HADOPI decision and Philippine Supreme Court's recent decision on administrative censorship, this paper proposes a discussion toward an international consensus on broadening the concept of censorship to include post-publication administrative censorship.

Keywords: censorship, administrative censorship, prior restraint, Korean Communication Standards Commission, HADOPI, Internet

Suggested Citation

Park, Kyung Sin, Administrative Internet Censorship by Korea Communication Standards Commission (December 24, 2014). Soongsil Law Review, Vol. 33, January 2015, pp. 91-115, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2748307

Kyung Sin Park (Contact Author)

Korea University Law School ( email )

Seoul 136-701
Korea
+82 10 8809 4057 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
173
Abstract Views
898
Rank
325,946
PlumX Metrics