Barbarians at the Gate: Consumer-Driven Health Data Commons and the Transformation of Citizen Science
36 Pages Posted: 20 Mar 2016 Last revised: 11 Apr 2019
Date Written: December 1, 2016
This article introduces consumer-driven health information commons, which are institutional arrangements to empower groups of consenting individuals to collaborate to assemble powerful, large-scale health data resources for use in scientific research, on terms the group members themselves would set through collective self-governance processes. Many of the grand scientific challenges of the 21st-century require access to big data resources that are both deeply descriptive (in the sense of containing detailed personal health, genomic, environmental, and lifestyle information about each individual) and inclusive (in the sense of supplying such data for many — sometimes, hundreds of millions — of individuals). These grand challenges include President Obama’s Precision Medicine and Brain Initiatives, the Vice President’s Cancer Moonshot, efforts by the National Institutes of Health and the Food and Drug Administration to clarify the clinical significance of genetic variants and to make modern diagnostics safe and effective, and attempts to create a “learning health care system” that harnesses healthcare data to improve patient care. Without big data resources, these efforts will fail.
Current research and privacy regulations, which were designed for clinical research and for small-data studies of the past, cannot support creation of the vast data resources that 21st-century science needs. These regulations enshrine data-holders (hospitals, insurers, and other entities that store people’s data) as the prime movers in assembling large-scale data resources for scientific use and rely on mechanisms — such as de-identification of data and waivers of individual consent — that are unworkable going forward. They shower individuals with unwanted, paternalistic protections — such as barriers to access to their own research results — while denying them a voice in what will be done with their data.
Keywords: precision medicine, citizen science, data commons, privacy, interoperable health data resources
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation