Between Intentional Discrimination and Discriminatory Side Effects

44 Israel Yearbook on Human Rights 87 (2014)

25 Pages Posted: 27 Mar 2016

See all articles by Iddo Porat

Iddo Porat

College of Law and Business - Ramat Gan Law School

Date Written: November 1, 2014

Abstract

The courts in the United States have distinguished between acts of intentional discrimination and acts that involve only unintended discriminatory impact or side effects. Such disparate impact cases are outside the protection of the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause. The focus of this paper will be on cases that lie in between intentional and side effect discrimination, i.e., cases in which we would be hard pressed to define the discrimination as intentional, but that nonetheless consist of something more than benign acts with unintentional adverse side effects on minority groups. One such intermediate category that I wish to explore in this paper is the category of discrimination out of indifference towards the discriminatory effect. How should we view cases in which the governmental actor, while not motivated by the wish to discriminate, is completely indifferent to the possibility of discrimination? In the article, I explore the moral standing of indifference and argue that we might have reason to believe that it is on par with the moral standing of intent. I move on to apply this insight to constitutional law and give examples of indifference in anti-discrimination law and whether it, too, can be considered on par with intention.

Keywords: Discrimination, Intention, Intentional Discrimination, Knobe Effect

JEL Classification: K10

Suggested Citation

Porat, Iddo, Between Intentional Discrimination and Discriminatory Side Effects (November 1, 2014). 44 Israel Yearbook on Human Rights 87 (2014). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2755223

Iddo Porat (Contact Author)

College of Law and Business - Ramat Gan Law School ( email )

26 Ben-Gurion St.
Ramat Gan, 52275
Israel

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
23
Abstract Views
236
PlumX