Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Speech or Conduct: The Free Speech Claims of Wedding Vendors

62 Pages Posted: 26 Apr 2016 Last revised: 31 Aug 2017

Caroline Mala Corbin

University of Miami School of Law

Date Written: April 25, 2016

Abstract

As LGBT rights have expanded, so have claims by businesses that public accommodation laws banning sexual orientation discrimination violate their free speech rights. In particular, wedding vendors such as bakers and photographers claim that forcing them to serve LGBT customers compels them to express approval of same-sex marriage — something contrary to their religious beliefs. The question addressed by this Article is not whether public accommodations laws ultimately violate the Free Speech Clause, but whether they even require free speech review. In other words, is baking a cake for a same-sex wedding or photographing the bride-and-bride “speech” triggering free speech scrutiny?

Both bakers and photographers raise compelled expressive conduct claims, a little analyzed category. Given the context of a business open to the public selling a service, the bakers’ claim that baking a cake is expressive conduct ought to be rejected. The photographers’ claim is more complicated: because photography is a traditional mode of communication, the claim raises the additional question of whether conduct involving words or images necessarily amounts to speech that is covered by the Free Speech Clause.

Keywords: Speech, Religion, First Amendment, expressive conduct, symbolic conduct, exemptions, bakers, wedding cakes, photographers, wedding photographs, Elane Photography, Masterpiece, Masterpiece Cakeshop, Spence test

Suggested Citation

Corbin, Caroline Mala, Speech or Conduct: The Free Speech Claims of Wedding Vendors (April 25, 2016). Emory Law Journal, Vol. 65, No. 241, 2016; University of Miami Legal Studies Research Paper No. 16-21. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2769949

Caroline Mala Corbin (Contact Author)

University of Miami School of Law ( email )

1311 Miller Drive
Coral Gables, FL 33146
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
137
Rank
177,502
Abstract Views
966