Integrative Bioethics: A Conceptually Inconsistent Project

11 Pages Posted: 12 May 2016

See all articles by Viktor Ivanković

Viktor Ivanković

Central European University (CEU) - Central European Univeristy - Doctoral School of Political Science, International Relations, and Public Policy

Lovro Savić

University of Groningen - Department of Ethics, Social and Political Philosophy

Date Written: June 2016

Abstract

This article provides a critical evaluation of the central components of Integrative Bioethics, a project aiming at a bioethical framework reconceptualization. Its proponents claim that this new system of thought has developed a better bioethical methodology than mainstream Western bioethics, a claim that we criticize here. We deal especially with the buzz words of Integrative Bioethics – pluriperspectivism, integrativity, orientational knowledge, as well as with its underlying theory of moral truth. The first part of the paper looks at what the claims of a superior methodology consist in. The second reveals pluriperspectivism and integrativity to be underdeveloped, hazy terms, but which seem to be underpinned by two theses – the incommensurability and the inclusiveness theses. These theses we critically scrutinize. We then consider strategies the project's proponents might apply to curb these theses in order to acquire minimal consistency for their framework. This part of the article also deals with the conception of moral truth that drives the theory, a position equally burdened with inconsistencies. In the last part of the article, we observe the concept of orientational knowledge, and develop two interpretations of its possible meaning. We claim that, following the first interpretation, Integrative Bioethics is completely descriptive, in which case it is informative and important, but hardly bioethics; if it is normative, following the second interpretation, it is bioethics as we already know it, but merely clad in rhetorical embellishments. We conclude that there is nothing new about this project, and that its inconsistencies are reason enough for its abandonment.

Keywords: Integrative Bioethics, pluriperspectivism, integrativity, orientational knowledge, incommensurability, inclusiveness, normativity

Suggested Citation

Ivanković, Viktor and Savić, Lovro, Integrative Bioethics: A Conceptually Inconsistent Project (June 2016). Bioethics, Vol. 30, Issue 5, pp. 325-335, 2016, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2778841 or http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12235

Viktor Ivanković (Contact Author)

Central European University (CEU) - Central European Univeristy - Doctoral School of Political Science, International Relations, and Public Policy ( email )

Nador 9
Budapest, 1051
Hungary

Lovro Savić

University of Groningen - Department of Ethics, Social and Political Philosophy

9712 CP Groningen
Netherlands

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
1
Abstract Views
169
PlumX Metrics