18 Pages Posted: 15 May 2016 Last revised: 19 Jan 2017
Date Written: May 12, 2016
Corporations are subject to broad criminal liability for the insider trading of their employees. Critics have noted that this results in a harsh irony. “After all,” Professor Jonathan Macey argues, “it is generally the employer who is harmed by the insider trading.” In the same vein, former chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Harvey L. Pitt and Karen L. Shapiro point out that, “[f]ar from being responsible for their employees’ violations of the law…most of the employers who have had the unfortunate experience of employing [insider traders] are in fact the only true victims, in an otherwise victimless crime.”
It is clear that not all insider trading is victimless, and not all employers of insider traders are innocent. But I am convinced that these critics are correct to point out that the current enforcement regime is absurdly overbroad in that it affords no principled guarantee to corporate victims of insider trading that they will not be indicted for the crimes perpetrated against them.
The law should be reformed to insure that corporations are only held criminally liable where they are guilty of some wrongdoing. Section I of this Article outlines current law in the United States concerning corporate criminal liability in general. Section II then looks at corporate liability for insider trading under the current regime. Section III explains why the current regime is absurdly overbroad and in dire need of reform. Section IV then points the way to some reforms that would render corporate criminal liability for insider trading more rational, efficient, and just.
Keywords: Insider Trading, Corporate Criminal Liability, White Collar Crime, Securities
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Anderson, John P., When Does Corporate Criminal Liability for Insider Trading Make Sense? (May 12, 2016). 46 Stetson L. Rev. 147 (2016); Mississippi College School of Law Research Paper No. 2016-07. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2779136
By Manuel Utset