The Prosecutor Called Them 'Insurance Company Wreckers': The Charter Oak Trial of 1878

87 Pages Posted: 18 May 2016

See all articles by Henry S. Cohn

Henry S. Cohn

Connecticut Superior Court

Adam Tarr

O'Brien, Tanski & Young LLP

Date Written: December 1, 2015


On January 7, 1894, the New York Times declared that Connecticut Governor Luzon B. Morris's appointment of Superior Court Judge William Hamersley to the Connecticut Supreme Court ensured that the Court "will become Democratic for the first time in thirty years..." The article related that both Democrats and Republicans hastened to support Hamersley as one of Hartford's finest citizens and a brilliant lawyer as well. "For twenty years," the author wrote, "Judge Hamersley was State's Attorney here, and was pitted against the ablest lawyers in the country in the great Charter Oak Life conspiracy case in 1878... The energy which he displayed as a Public Prosecutor was phenomenal."

For a case that the New York Times deemed "great," there has been hardly anything written about the "Great Charter Oak Life" criminal conspiracy. The only record of the whole affair appeared in 1897 as a chapter in P. Henry Woodward's Insurance in Connecticut. It is striking that the history books are virtually silent on a trial in Hartford Superior Court, reported on by national newspapers and lasting over twenty days. The trial pitted Hamersley as prosecutor against Leonard Swett-a world-renowned attorney and one of Abraham Lincoln's closest friends.

This article traces the history of that trial and the surrounding events from its origins in 1877 to its conclusion in January 1879. The trial is important not only for its personalities, but for its influence on the regulation of the insurance industry in the "city of insurance."

Keywords: Charter Oak, Hamersley, Swett, Insurance, 19th Century, Trials

Suggested Citation

Cohn, Henry S. and Tarr, Adam, The Prosecutor Called Them 'Insurance Company Wreckers': The Charter Oak Trial of 1878 (December 1, 2015). Quinnipiac Law Review, Vol. 34, No. 1, 2015, Available at SSRN:

Henry S. Cohn (Contact Author)

Connecticut Superior Court ( email )

Adam Tarr

O'Brien, Tanski & Young LLP

185 Asylum St
Hartford, CT 06103
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics