The Execution of the Innocent in Military Tribunals: Problems from the Past and Solutions for the Future

66 Pages Posted: 31 May 2016 Last revised: 13 Feb 2018

See all articles by Justin Walker

Justin Walker

University of Louisville - Louis D. Brandeis School of Law

Date Written: April 27, 2016

Abstract

For the past fifteen years, the United States has struggled with the question of how to administer military tribunals. During that time, most commentators have assumed that the right to a speedy trial that protects traditional criminal defendants also benefits military tribunal defendants. But in the context of military tribunals, history suggests that delay is good for defendants – especially innocent defendants. This is perhaps best illustrated by two previous military tribunals: the Dakota War tribunals of 1862 and the German Saboteurs tribunal from World War II. Those earlier tribunals led to the conviction and execution of defendants who were likely innocent. These injustices were largely the result of the public fear and hysteria surrounding the military events precipitating the tribunals, which in turn caused structural infirmities in the tribunals like denial of counsel, unreliable evidence, unnecessary secrecy, biased decision makers, and hastiness. If the tribunals had been sufficiently delayed, the hysteria likely would have abided, and the structural infirmities would likely have been either improved or even cured. If military tribunals are going to be used in the future, we should remember the benefits of, and insist on, a new right for defendants to delay the tribunals.

Keywords: military tribunals, military commissions, national security, international law, terrorism, Guantanamo, criminal procedure, German saboteurs, Dakota War, World War II, Al Qaeda

Suggested Citation

Walker, Justin, The Execution of the Innocent in Military Tribunals: Problems from the Past and Solutions for the Future (April 27, 2016). West Virginia Law Review, Vol. 119, No. 1, 2016, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2786679

Justin Walker (Contact Author)

University of Louisville - Louis D. Brandeis School of Law ( email )

2301 S 3rd St.
Louisville, KY 40208
502-852-6638 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
118
Abstract Views
676
Rank
466,441
PlumX Metrics