Why Now is the Time to Statutorily Ban Insider Trading Under the Equality of Access Theory

William & Mary Business Law Review (Volume 7, Issue 2, March 2016)

72 Pages Posted: 24 Jun 2016

See all articles by Bruce W. Klaw

Bruce W. Klaw

University of Denver, Daniels College of Business; University of Denver, Daniels College of Business, Dept. of Business Ethics and Legal Studies

Date Written: March 2016

Abstract

This Article makes the case for a new U.S. statutory provision that defines and prohibits insider trading under an "equality of access" theory. It supports this claim, and contributes to the important public dialogue concerning this prevalent practice, by highlighting the moral and legal gaps in existing U.S. law that result from understanding the harms of trading on the basis of material nonpublic information solely with reference to fiduciary breach or misappropriation, as evidenced by the recent cases of United States v. Newman and United States v. Salman. It weaves legal analysis together with current literature in business ethics, moral philosophy, finance, and accounting to consolidate and offer new arguments in the long-standing debate over insider trading based on Rawlsian social contract theory, applied deontology, and empirically informed utilitarianism. It then draws on lessons learned from empirical analysis of European states' adoption of the equality of access theory under the Market Abuse Directive. Finally, it analyzes three insider trading bills currently pending in Congress and makes the case for a statute, like S. 702, that will prohibit the use, by anyone, of material information concerning a financial instrument that is not, at least in principle, available to others through independent and otherwise lawful due diligence.

Keywords: Insider Trading, Securities, Fraud, Cheating, Newman, Salman, Business Ethics, Utilitarianism, Market Abuse

JEL Classification: K14, K22, K42

Suggested Citation

Klaw, Bruce W., Why Now is the Time to Statutorily Ban Insider Trading Under the Equality of Access Theory (March 2016). William & Mary Business Law Review (Volume 7, Issue 2, March 2016), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2799917

Bruce W. Klaw (Contact Author)

University of Denver, Daniels College of Business ( email )

2101 S. University Blvd.
Denver, CO 80210
United States

University of Denver, Daniels College of Business, Dept. of Business Ethics and Legal Studies ( email )

2101 S. University Blvd
Denver, CO 80208-8921
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
63
Abstract Views
1,172
rank
408,940
PlumX Metrics