Between Title IX and the Criminal Law: Bringing Tort Law to the Campus Sexual Assault Debate

24 Pages Posted: 14 Aug 2016  

Sarah Lynnda Swan

Columbia University, Law School

Date Written: August 8, 2016

Abstract

In the last few years, campus sexual assault has risen to prominence as a national public concern. As policy-makers scramble to figure out how best to address this problem, the contours of the conversation in scholarship, media articles, and policy-making have devolved into two competing adjudicative frameworks: criminal law or Title IX. In this criminal law versus Title IX debate, two questions dominate. First, who can better adjudicate claims of campus sexual assault: criminal courts using criminal laws, or schools using Title IX? Second, if schools do adjudicate sexual assault claims under Title IX, are students entitled to the same procedural protections as criminal defendants? In this Symposium piece, I argue that this criminal law versus Title IX framing is unduly narrow. It ignores a third, important mode of adjudication for sexual assault claims: tort law. In this essay, I show why tort law has been left out of the campus sexual assault debate, and the potential impact of its inclusion. Incorporating tort law into the campus sexual assault debate has three specific benefits. First, conceptualizing campus sexual assault as a tort reminds us that the same wrong can be legitimately framed and addressed in multiple ways. Second, tort law sets a useful standard for determining the scope of procedural protections in campus sexual assault proceedings. Third, tort law suggests that affirmative consent may be appropriate for campus sexual interactions. Ultimately, bringing tort law into the campus sexual assault debate opens up the vast and fertile ground between the two poles of criminal law and Title IX, and creates a space where better institutional design and a more effective solution to this social problem might be found.

Suggested Citation

Swan, Sarah Lynnda, Between Title IX and the Criminal Law: Bringing Tort Law to the Campus Sexual Assault Debate (August 8, 2016). Kansas Law Review, Vol. 64, 2016, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2820293

Sarah Lynnda Swan (Contact Author)

Columbia University, Law School ( email )

435 West 116th Street
New York, NY 10025
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
69
Rank
271,367
Abstract Views
250