Uncontrolled Experiments from the Laboratories of Democracy: Traditional Cash Welfare, Federalism, and Welfare Reform

Chapter 5 of The Law and Economics of Federalism, ed. Jonathan Klick, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. (2016)

U of Penn Law School, Public Law Research Paper No. 16-37

60 Pages Posted: 12 Sep 2016 Last revised: 28 Oct 2016

See all articles by Jonah B. Gelbach

Jonah B. Gelbach

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law

Date Written: May 5, 2016

Abstract

In this chapter I discuss the history and basic incentive effects of two key U.S. cash assistance programs aimed at families with children. Starting roughly in the 1980s, critics of the Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program argued that the program -- designed largely to cut relatively small checks -- failed to end poverty or promote work. After years of federally provided waivers that allowed states to experiment with changes to their AFDC programs, the critics in 1996 won the outright elimination of AFDC. It was replaced by the Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) program, over which states have enormous design discretion. In this chapter I argue that the empirical evidence on AFDC’s behavioral impact was never as compelling as AFDC’s critics maintained. Nor, for the period up to about 2012 (the endpoint of this chapter's analysis), is there any substantial empirical evidence supporting what I call the “triumphalist” position that the wave of state and federal welfare reforms that took place in the 1990s importantly explains the observed increase in employment among single mothers. Either the economic boom of the late 1990s, or some other difficult-to-measure change, appears to have played a more important role than welfare reform. What is more, the uncontrolled experimentation of the last two decades has left the U.S. with a crazyquilt collection of state programs that do not lend themselves to the kind of empirical research that would be necessary to benefit from the Brandeisian idea of states as laboratories of democracy.

Keywords: welfare, federalism, cash assistance, AFDC, TANF, PRWORA, welfare reform

JEL Classification: J01, J08, J12, J13, J18, J21, K36, H24, H31, H53, H71, H75, I31, I32, I38

Suggested Citation

Gelbach, Jonah B., Uncontrolled Experiments from the Laboratories of Democracy: Traditional Cash Welfare, Federalism, and Welfare Reform (May 5, 2016). Chapter 5 of The Law and Economics of Federalism, ed. Jonathan Klick, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. (2016); U of Penn Law School, Public Law Research Paper No. 16-37. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2837017 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2837017

Jonah B. Gelbach (Contact Author)

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law ( email )

215 Boalt Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-7200
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
59
Abstract Views
782
rank
376,963
PlumX Metrics