33 Pages Posted: 19 Oct 2016
Date Written: September 19, 2016
We partner with a major telecommunications provider to study the effect of Time-Shift TV (TSTV) on TV consumption. TSTV automatically records in the cloud programs that were broadcasted live for the past few days and thus allows users to watch the programs they want when they want. In 2012, our industrial partner deployed TSTV to half the TV channels it offered to premium consumers. Using difference-in-differences with Inverse Probability of Treatment Weighting we find that, on average, the introduction of TSTV increased the consumption of daily TV by 11 minutes (p < 0.01), from a baseline of 3.4 hours, and did not change the consumption of live TV. Furthermore, we find that the concentration of TV consumption increased after TSTV was available. In 2015, our industrial partner ran a randomized experiment in which a random set of households was selected to obtain access to a new set of TV channels broadcasting movies and TV shows. A random subset of these households obtained access to these channels with TSTV and another random subset of them obtained access to these channels without TSTV. Using difference-in-differences we find that, on average, the former set of households consumed 4.5 more minutes of TV per day (p < 0.01), from a baseline of 5.0 hours, and as much live TV as the latter set of households. In addition, the consumption of TV by the former set of households was more concentrated towards the most popular programs. Finally, we show that households do not seem to use TSTV as a new tool to strategically avoid ads. In particular, and in 2015, households given access to the new TV channels with TSTV exit ads in the original TV channels as much as the households given access to these channels without TSTV. Therefore, the concern of advertisers that TSTV may reduce their revenues is unwarranted. However, advertisers do not have data on TV audiences. Instead, content distributors do. Therefore, the latter are in a unique powerful position to deploy auction-based systems to sell TV ad slots taking advantage of the fine-grained information they have on TV viewership, much like websites do today online using cookies.
Keywords: TV, TSTV, DVR, TIVO, Randomized Experiment, Media
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Belo, Rodrigo and Ferreira, Pedro and Godinho de Matos, Miguel and Reis, Filipa, The Impact of Time-Shift TV on TV Viewership and on Ad Consumption: Results from Both Natural and Randomized Experiments (September 19, 2016). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2854704