The Signal and the Noise in Administrative Law

Forthcoming, University of New Brunswick Law Journal

University of Cambridge Faculty of Law Research Paper No. 3/2017

15 Pages Posted: 25 Nov 2016 Last revised: 28 Apr 2017

Paul Daly

University of Cambridge - Faculty of Law

Date Written: November 22, 2016

Abstract

There has been an unfortunate trend in recent Supreme Court of Canada administrative law cases. While academics, practitioners and lower-court judges try to establish coherent frameworks to understand the general principles of judicial review, the Court has been resolving cases one by one without, with respect, any serious attempt to explain how they fit into its existing body of jurisprudence. The institutional context in which the Court operates, explained in Part I, no doubt influences the Court’s resolution of individual cases in this way.

Whatever the background institutional context, confusion is the result, as I explain in Part II. How should lawyers read these cases: as attempts to resolve one-off issues of substantive law (workers’ compensation law, immigration law, discrimination law and so on) or as continual refinements to an already complex body of administrative law doctrine?

I argue in this paper that it is now necessary to distinguish between signal and noise, between those cases that do modify administrative law doctrine and those cases that simply deal with a particular substantive area of law. In Part III, I set out criteria which will help Canadian administrative lawyers to distinguish signal from noise.

This confusion seems to me, however, to be unnecessary. As I suggest in Part IV, the Court could take up judicial and academic proposals for a unified reasonableness standard that would allow it to resolve individual cases without creating uncertainty about whether it has also modified administrative law doctrine. Adopting this approach would obviate the need to distinguish signal from noise, because they would both fade into the comforting hum of reasonableness review.

Keywords: judicial review, stare decisis, obiter, Canada, administrative law

Suggested Citation

Daly, Paul, The Signal and the Noise in Administrative Law (November 22, 2016). Forthcoming, University of New Brunswick Law Journal; University of Cambridge Faculty of Law Research Paper No. 3/2017. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2874310 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2874310

Paul Daly (Contact Author)

University of Cambridge - Faculty of Law ( email )

10 West Road
Cambridge, CB3 9DZ
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
404
rank
66,010
Abstract Views
1,166
PlumX