Categorical Exclusions from Capital Punishment: How Many Wrongs Make a Right?

50 Pages Posted: 3 Jan 2017

See all articles by Dorie Klein

Dorie Klein

St. Mary's University School of Law

Date Written: 2007

Abstract

The two categorical exclusions of age and mental capacity will impact not only those offenders who are excluded from the death penalty, but also those offenders who remain subject to this punishment. The Supreme Court’s decisions in Roper v. Simmons and Atkins v. Virginia raise the issue that a capital-punishment-limiting decision possesses wrongs of its own. Both decisions limit the death penalty — Roper excludes from this punishment offenders who committed their crimes before they were eighteen years old and Atkins excludes offenders who are mentally retarded. But in both cases, the Supreme Court overstated the uniformity and universality of traits associated with diminished culpability among juvenile and mentally retarded offenders. Contrary to that impression, not all offenders who are excluded from the death penalty under Atkins and Roper are necessarily less culpable than are offenders who remain subject to this punishment.

Categorical exclusions such as age and culpability might solve the problem of improperly sentenced mentally retarded or juvenile offenders, but they raise other problems. The Roper Court failed to consider those problems, and the Atkins Court could not possibly have considered those problems because accepting the Court's reasoning requires denying that these problems even exist. Although the many wrongs of capital punishment provide strong motivation for believing that the Atkins and Roper decisions are right, the rightness of these decisions becomes far from certain when the consequences for non-excluded offenders are considered. Capital punishment after Atkins and Roper might appear to be more just, but this appearance is misleading.

Keywords: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty, Roper v. Simmons, Atkins v. Virginia, Mentally Retarded, Eighteen Years Old, Juvenile, Categorical Exclusions, Non-Juvenile, Non-Mentally Retarded, Culpability, Age, Mental Abilities, Cognitive Abilities, American Psychiatric Association, American Association of Me

Suggested Citation

Klein, Dorie, Categorical Exclusions from Capital Punishment: How Many Wrongs Make a Right? (2007). Brooklyn Law Review, Vol. 72, 2007, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2891963

Dorie Klein (Contact Author)

St. Mary's University School of Law ( email )

One Camino Santa Maria
San Antonio, TX 78228-8602
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
62
Abstract Views
1,339
rank
497,736
PlumX Metrics