Curse or Blessing? How Institutions Determine Success in Resource-Rich Economies

48 Pages Posted: 18 Feb 2017

See all articles by Peter Kaznacheev

Peter Kaznacheev

Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA) - Center for Raw Materials Economy

Date Written: January 11, 2017

Abstract

One of the main reasons for the drop in oil prices that began in 2014 was a rapid increase in U.S. oil production—it reached the level of the other two biggest producers, Russia and Saudi Arabia, that same year. That, in turn, decreased U.S. demand for imported petroleum and hence put downward pressure on the oil price worldwide. There is one aspect of the shale revolution that gets much less attention than geopolitical or environmental issues: What were the institutional conditions that allowed the technological innovation to happen? In essence, it was a combination of secure property rights, a favorable tax regime, minimal red tape, and a strong entrepreneurial culture (there were around 13,000 small U.S. oil companies fiercely competing with each other).

This paper explains how the quality of institutions determines whether natural resource abundance is a blessing or a curse: Will it boost or stifle innovation and economic development? Institutional deficiency in resource economies perpetuates rent-seeking, autocracy, and slower economic growth as illustrated by multiple examples. One of the most alarming among them is Venezuela. While the country possesses the largest oil reserves in the world it is at a brink of economic collapse and is struggling with mass food shortages.

Nonetheless, the evidence presented in this paper is at odds with the “resource curse” hypothesis that mineral-exporting countries are doomed to stagnation. A number of countries with high levels of economic freedom, such as Australia, Canada, Chile, and Norway, demonstrate that it is possible to build a prosperous and innovative economy with a significant share of income from the sale of minerals. Furthermore, sound institutions can help diversify the economy and weather the storm of low commodity prices. As exemplified by several countries in the 1980s and in later years, petroleum exporters with strong institutions can achieve positive growth even during oil price drops.

Keywords: Natural Resources, Natural Gas, Oil Prices, International Economy, International Trade

JEL Classification: F1, Q41, Q43, Q48, Q3

Suggested Citation

Kaznacheev, Peter, Curse or Blessing? How Institutions Determine Success in Resource-Rich Economies (January 11, 2017). Cato Institute Policy Analysis No. 808. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2919443

Peter Kaznacheev (Contact Author)

Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA) - Center for Raw Materials Economy ( email )

Moscow
Russia

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
103
Abstract Views
609
rank
265,768
PlumX Metrics