Skin or Skim? Inside Investment and Hedge Fund Performance

Abstract

Using a comprehensive and survivor-bias free dataset of U.S. hedge funds, we document the role that inside investment plays in managerial compensation and fund performance. We find that funds with greater investment by insiders outperform funds with less “skin in the game” on a factor-adjusted basis; exhibit greater return persistence; and feature lower fund flow-performance sensitivities. These results suggest that managers earn outsize rents by operating trading strategies further from their capacity constraints when managing their own money. Our findings have implications for optimal portfolio allocations of institutional investors and models of delegated asset management.

Keywords: Hedge Funds, Ownership, Managerial Skill, Alpha, Compensation

JEL Classification: G23, G32, J33, J54