Ban on Planned Parenthood Funding is an Unconstitutional Bill of Attainder

8 Pages Posted: 18 Jul 2017 Last revised: 20 Jul 2017

Robert A. Sedler

Wayne State University Law School

Date Written: July 18, 2017

Abstract

The denial of federal or state women’s health care funding for Planned Parenthood and other women’s health care providers that include abortions in the wide array of services that they provide to low-income women is an unconstitutional bill of attainder. A bill of attainder is a trial by a legislature in which the legislature enacts a law that is designed to punish a named person or an identifiable group of persons. It goes back to 16th, 17th and 18th century Great Britain, where Parliament would enact a law finding certain opponents of the Crown guilty of treason and confiscating their property. And during the Revolutionary War, all of the colonial legislatures used bills of attainder to confiscate the property of British loyalists. The Framers of the Constitution were determined to put an end to this pernicious practice and so unanimously and without debate, specifically provided in the Constitution that “no bill of attainder shall be passed by Congress or by any state.”

The Supreme Court has interpreted the constitutional prohibition against bills of attainder very broadly, going beyond the imposition of a criminal penalty. Rather the Court has applied a functional test to prohibit legislative punishment of any form or severity against specifically designated persons or groups. Under this test, the denial of a governmental benefit to an organization otherwise eligible to receive it on the ground that the organization enabled women to exercise their fundamental right to have a safe and legal abortion clearly constituted punishment, and by definition, there could be no legitimate non-punitive purpose served by this denial. It is thus an unconstitutional bill of attainder. It has no place in the American constitutional system.

Suggested Citation

Sedler, Robert A., Ban on Planned Parenthood Funding is an Unconstitutional Bill of Attainder (July 18, 2017). Wayne State University Law School Research Paper No. 2017-31. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3004878 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3004878

Robert A. Sedler (Contact Author)

Wayne State University Law School ( email )

471 Palmer
Detroit, MI 48202
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
85
rank
272,936
Abstract Views
320
PlumX