Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Crime, Punishment, and Causation: The Effect of Etiological Information on the Perception of Moral Agency

41 Pages Posted: 2 Aug 2017  

Philip Robbins

University of Missouri - Department of Philosophy

Paul Litton

University of Missouri School of Law

Date Written: August 1, 2017

Abstract

Moral judgments about a situation are profoundly shaped by the perception of individuals in that situation as either moral agents or moral patients (Gray & Wegner, 2009; Gray, Young, & Waytz, 2012). Specifically, the more we see someone as a moral agent, the less we see them as a moral patient, and vice versa. As a result, casting the perpetrator of a transgression as a victim tends to have the effect of making them seem less blameworthy (Gray & Wegner, 2011). Based on this theoretical framework, we predicted that criminal offenders with a mental disorder that predisposes them to antisocial behavior would be judged more negatively when the disorder is described as having a genetic origin than when it is described as environmentally caused, as in the case of childhood abuse or accident. Further, we predicted that some environmental explanations would mitigate attributions of blame more than others, namely, that offenders whose disorder was caused by childhood abuse (intentional harm) would be seen as less blameworthy than offenders whose disorder is caused by an unfortunate accident (unintentional harm). Results from two vignette-based studies designed to test these predictions, conducted with participants recruited from Amazon Mechanical Turk (N = 244 and N = 387, respectively), confirmed the first prediction but not the second. Implications of this research for three areas — the psychology of moral judgment, philosophical debates about moral responsibility and determinism, and the practice of the law — are discussed in the sequel.

Keywords: experimental philosophy, free will, moral typecasting; blame; punishment; responsibility; causation

Suggested Citation

Robbins, Philip and Litton, Paul, Crime, Punishment, and Causation: The Effect of Etiological Information on the Perception of Moral Agency (August 1, 2017). Psychology, Public Policy, and Law (Forthcoming); University of Missouri School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2017-21. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3012201

Philip Robbins

University of Missouri - Department of Philosophy ( email )

332 Cornell Hall
Columbia, MO Columbia 65211
United States

Paul Litton (Contact Author)

University of Missouri School of Law ( email )

Missouri Avenue & Conley Avenue
Columbia, MO 65211
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
105
Rank
220,660
Abstract Views
526