Best Buys and Own Brands: Investment Platforms’ Recommendations of Mutual Funds

Abstract

Individuals increasingly buy mutual funds via on-line platforms, whose ‘best buy’ recommendations heavily influence flows. As intermediaries of mutual funds, platforms provide none of the unobservable interaction or intangible benefits of brokers, and so allow clean tests of the determinants, influence, and value, of their fund recommendations. Using unique U.K. data, we find that platforms favor ‘own brand’ funds and those paying them a higher commission share. Investors discount own-brand recommendations, but not those paying high commission shares (which were not observable in the UK). A regulatory ban on commission-sharing lowered costs and improved the informativeness of platform recommendations.

Keywords: Mutual Funds, Investment Platforms, Recommendations

JEL Classification: G11, G20