Agencies and Science-Experiment Risk

61 Pages Posted: 20 Sep 2017

See all articles by Eric E. Johnson

Eric E. Johnson

University of Oklahoma College of Law

Date Written: 2016

Abstract

There is a curious absence of legal constraints on U.S. government agencies undertaking potentially risky scientific research. Some of these activities may present a risk of killing millions or even destroying the planet. Current law leaves it to agencies to decide for themselves whether their activities fall within the bounds of acceptable risk. This Article explores to what extent and under what circumstances the law ought to allow private actions against such non-regulatory agency endeavors. Engaging with this issue is not only interesting in its own right, it allows us to test fundamental concepts of agency competence and the role of the courts.

Two case studies provide a foundation for discussion: NASA’s use of plutonium power supplies on spacecraft, which critics say could cause millions of cancers in the event of atmospheric disintegration, and a Department of Energy particle-collider experiment that allegedly poses a small risk of collapsing the Earth. These extreme examples serve as a test-bed for applying insights from neoclassical economics, behavioral economics, risk-management studies, and cognitive psychology. The resulting analysis suggests that in low-probability/high-harm scenarios, agencies are likely to do a poor job of judging the acceptability of risk to the public. Instead, generalist judges working in a common-law vein may have surprising advantages. This in turns suggests that under certain circumstances the government should be subject to legal action that provides non-deferential review of discretionary agency actions that are non-regulatory in nature.

Keywords: administrative law, science, risk, regulation, catastrophe, judicial review, economics, behavioral economics, space exploration, nuclear physics, particle physics

JEL Classification: D8, D81, K2, K23, K32

Suggested Citation

Johnson, Eric E., Agencies and Science-Experiment Risk (2016). University of Illinois Law Review, Vol. 2016, No. 2, 2016, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3038989

Eric E. Johnson (Contact Author)

University of Oklahoma College of Law ( email )

300 Timberdell Road
Norman, OK 73019
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
31
Abstract Views
565
PlumX Metrics