Exploring Disagreement in Indicators of State Repression
22 Pages Posted: 20 Oct 2017 Last revised: 30 Oct 2017
Date Written: October 4, 2017
Until recently, researchers who wanted to examine the determinants of state respect for most specific negative rights needed to rely on data from the CIRI or the Political Terror Scale (PTS). The new V-DEM dataset offers scholars a potential alternative to the individual human rights variables from CIRI. We analyze a set of key Cingranelli-Richards (CIRI) Human Rights Data Project and Varieties of Democracy (V-DEM) negative rights indicators, finding unusual and unexpectedly large patterns of disagreement between the two sets. First, we discuss the new V-DEM dataset by comparing it to the disaggregated CIRI indicators, discussing the history of each project, and describing its empirical domain. Second, we identify a set of disaggregated human rights measures that are similar across the two datasets and discuss each project’s measurement approach. Third, we examine how these measures compare to each other empirically, showing that they diverge considerably across both time and space. Our findings indicate that researchers should think carefully about using the measures as substitutes. They also suggest a set of empirical and theoretical puzzles and several important directions for future work.
Keywords: measurement, repression, human rights, indicators, international law
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation