Immanence and Irreconcilability: On the Character of Public Law as Political Jurisprudence

Forthcoming in: M. Wilkinson & M. Dowdle (eds.), Questioning the Foundations of Public Law (Hart Publishing)

LSE Legal Studies Working Paper No. 19/2017

24 Pages Posted: 18 Jan 2018

See all articles by Jacco Bomhoff

Jacco Bomhoff

London School of Economics - Law Department

Date Written: December 7, 2017

Abstract

In Foundations of Public Law, Martin Loughlin constructs an intricate conceptual triangle made up out of religion, law, and politics, in order to offer an account of the character of public law as a secular, political, jurisprudence. In this essay, I argue that this account takes neither religion nor law seriously - and this in revealingly similar ways.

Loughlin’s book presents public law as an irreducibly paradoxical discourse, devoted to sustaining ‘the irreconcilable’ within society. Relative to this discourse, religion - understood by Loughlin as absolutist dogma - appears in the book only as a threat, whereas law - seen as a mere tool - becomes a necessary and innocent means for its support. I offer a critique of both these lines of argument, as not sufficiently attentive to religion and law as fields with their own histories, internal dynamics, and forms of efficacy. Religion, when seen in terms of practice, discipline, and ritual, in fact has much in common with - and considerable resources to offer to - Loughlin’s own vision of public law. And attention to the legalism so deeply embedded in juristic discourse reveals law as posing precisely the absolutist threat that Loughlin fears (but only associates with religion and ‘the social’).

Bringing these two lines of argument together, I argue that Loughlin’s own ambition for public law as a prudential discourse of contained irreconcilability, is better served, not by striving for radical - and impossible - immanence, but by acknowledging that discourse’s dual character as a phenomenon both immanent and transcendent. I also suggest that ritual practice may have an important role to play in maintaining this dual, and paradoxical, character.

Suggested Citation

Bomhoff, Jacco, Immanence and Irreconcilability: On the Character of Public Law as Political Jurisprudence (December 7, 2017). Forthcoming in: M. Wilkinson & M. Dowdle (eds.), Questioning the Foundations of Public Law (Hart Publishing); LSE Legal Studies Working Paper No. 19/2017. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3083954 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3083954

Jacco Bomhoff (Contact Author)

London School of Economics - Law Department ( email )

Houghton Street
London WC2A 2AE, WC2A 2AE
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
93
rank
273,335
Abstract Views
622
PlumX Metrics
!

Under construction: SSRN citations will be offline until July when we will launch a brand new and improved citations service, check here for more details.

For more information