Regulating Competition and Property in the Digital Economy – The Interface Between Data, Privacy, Intellectual Property, Fairness and Competition Law

53 Pages Posted: 19 Jan 2018 Last revised: 27 Apr 2018

See all articles by Bjorn Lundqvist

Bjorn Lundqvist

Stockholm University - Faculty of Law

Date Written: January 17, 2018

Abstract

In the Internet of Things, access to Data regarding customers, markets and the industry as a whole will make the difference in reference to whether regular brick-and-mortar firms can compete successfully or whether they would fall foul of competition. These firms will often provide their Data to a Cloud. However, access to the Cloud on fair business terms and the possibility to Changes Cloud service provider seem to be increasingly difficult, especially for the brick-and-mortar firms, that soon will be connected to the Internet of Things. Indeed, the Cloud providers are increasingly controlling not only their own Data, but can alos access the Data provided by firms that purchase Cloud services. This article identifies and addresses these issues, and discusses whether Competition Law can address them, ex post, or whether there is a need for legislative measures, ex ante, so that brick-and-mortar firms may access and make use of all the possibilities that the Internet of Things harbours. More specifically, the article addresses whether brick-and-mortar firms should have some kind of right to port Data vis-a-vis Cloud providers so to address their needs, and also so to increase competition and rivalry. In the end, the author suggests that Competition Law can suffice as an effective tool in the Digital Economy, if the special consequences of indirect network effects and tipping are taken into consideration in the Competition Law analysis. The article thereby presents an antitrust goal, Interoperability, and discusses the notion of Interoperability (Neutrality) and why that could be a value to be protected under Competition Law in the Digital Economy. Several leading EU Competition Law cases such as the Microsoft, the Huawei and, also, the recent Commission Google case, being analysed in the article, can be explained based on the value of Interoperability. Moreover, Interoperability could be the theoretical reason to implement a right to port databases/datasets for the brick-and-mortar firms. Would Interoperability be infringed, Antitrust harm may be identified, while to promote Interoperability and Competition, the brick-and-mortar firms should have the right to port databases/datasets between Cloud providers, or back in-house.

Keywords: Digital Economy, The Cloud, Interoperability, Internet of Things, Industrial Internet, Standardization, SEP, Competition Law, Antitrust, Big Data, Open Data, Intellectual Property Law, Privacy, Data Protection, PSI, Platforms, Ecosystem, Interoperability Neutrality, Amazon, Google, Ericsson, Nokia

Suggested Citation

Lundqvist, Bjorn, Regulating Competition and Property in the Digital Economy – The Interface Between Data, Privacy, Intellectual Property, Fairness and Competition Law (January 17, 2018). Faculty of Law, Stockholm University Research Paper No. 54, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3103870

Bjorn Lundqvist (Contact Author)

Stockholm University - Faculty of Law ( email )

S-106 91 Stockholm
Sweden

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
750
Abstract Views
2,283
rank
39,633
PlumX Metrics