A Counterfactual History of Transgender Students' Rights

Journal of Constitutional Law Online, Vol. 20, 2017

32 Pages Posted: 29 Jan 2018 Last revised: 9 Oct 2018

Date Written: January 19, 2018


Disputes about transgender students’ rights are growing in number and prominence. In spring 2017, when the Trump Administration rescinded the Obama Administration’s guidance that had protected transgender students, the Supreme Court cancelled oral argument in Gloucester County v. G.G., the case it was scheduled to hear on this topic, vacated the lower court’s opinion, and remanded the case. But what if that hadn’t happened? Specifically, what if Hillary Clinton had been elected president, the guidance had remained in place, and the Court had heard oral argument as originally scheduled in Gloucester County? This piece employs the approach of counterfactual history, presenting what I believe would have been the Court’s decision in Gloucester County in an alternate reality: The Supreme Court would have sided with student Gavin Grimm on administrative law grounds with Justice Kennedy, the swing vote, giving the liberal justices their fifth vote. Continuing in this parallel universe, I take what surely would have been an initial reaction by transgender advocates — that the decision was “the Brown v. Board of transgender rights” — and test the limits of that statement. Finally, I return to the present day, reflecting on what we can learn from the counterfactual history, considering how that knowledge can inform our understanding of what happened and why, discussing the current and emerging litigation in this area, and analyzing the importance of policy choices at the state and local level.

Keywords: school, students, transgender, gender, Title IX, equality, Equal Protection, discrimination

Suggested Citation

Bowman, Kristine L., A Counterfactual History of Transgender Students' Rights (January 19, 2018). Journal of Constitutional Law Online, Vol. 20, 2017, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3105786

Kristine L. Bowman (Contact Author)

Michigan State University ( email )

620 Farm Lane
East Lansing, MI 48824-1300
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics