Charter Scrutiny of Canada's Medical Assistance in Dying Law and the Shifting Landscape of Belgian and Dutch Euthanasia Practice

(2018) 85 Supreme Court Law Review (2nd Series) 459-544

86 Pages Posted: 13 Apr 2018 Last revised: 12 Jun 2018

See all articles by Trudo Lemmens

Trudo Lemmens

University of Toronto - Faculty of Law

Date Written: April 3, 2018


In 2017, Canada's Parliament partially decriminalized "Medical Assistance in Dying" [MAID] (the term the law uses for euthanasia and physician assisted suicide) and allowed the practice in specific circumstances at the end of life. Canadian advocates of broad access to MAID have criticized the new legislation for being too restrictive, and particularly rejected the law's end-of-life access criteria of ‘reasonably foreseeable death’ and ‘irreversible decline of capabilities’. Two legal challenges have already been launched that aim at broadening the category of people who can access MAID. In these lawsuits, an analysis of what happens in jurisdictions that allow broad access to MAID, and a comparison with other jurisdictions that restrict access to end-of-life situations, could play an important role as it reveals why a restriction to the end-of-life context is important.

This paper provides such a comparison, and discusses in detail the most recent developments of the euthanasia practices in Belgium and the Netherlands, two jurisdictions with broad access to euthanasia without end-of-life restriction. This discussion, informed by many sources that are not available in English and that are quoted in translation, reveals why giving physicians discretionary power to decide who has access to MAID, on the basis of broad access criteria without restriction to the end-of-life context, risks undermining important legislative goals that are enumerated in Canada's MAID law. These include: the protection against errors and abuse; the protection of vulnerable people from being induced, in moments of weakness, to end their lives; the equal value of every person’s life and the avoidance of negative perceptions of the quality of life of persons who are elderly, ill, or disabled; and the prevention of suicide. The paper shows the most recent trends in Belgium and the Netherlands and discusses in particular growing controversies related to the expansion of euthanasia practices outside the end-of-life context and in the context of mental health. It discusses further the problems with the various safeguards in the Belgian and Dutch regimes, which are also increasingly becoming apparent. This analysis shows how a restriction of access to the end-of-life context is essential to ensure a reasonable balance between providing access and protecting the important human rights related goals embedded in the legislation.

Keywords: Medical Assistance in Dying, Euthanasia, Assisted Suicide, End of Life, Criminal Law, Constitutional Law, Right to Health Care, Vulnerability, Mental Health, Human Rights, Autonomy

Suggested Citation

Lemmens, Trudo, Charter Scrutiny of Canada's Medical Assistance in Dying Law and the Shifting Landscape of Belgian and Dutch Euthanasia Practice (April 3, 2018). (2018) 85 Supreme Court Law Review (2nd Series) 459-544, Available at SSRN:

Trudo Lemmens (Contact Author)

University of Toronto - Faculty of Law ( email )

78 and 84 Queen's Park
Toronto, Ontario M5S 2C5

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics