The Sounds of Silence: The Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt, Constitutional Crisis, and Constitutional Silence

Forthcoming in the International Journal of Constitutional Law's upcoming special issue on "Constitutional Silence."

14 Pages Posted: 18 Jul 2018

See all articles by Mohammad Fadel

Mohammad Fadel

University of Toronto - Faculty of Law

Date Written: July 1, 2018

Abstract

The Egyptian Supreme Constitutional Court (SCC) issued a series of decisive decisions during the transition period following Hosni Mubarak's resignation and the military coup of July 3, 2013. During the transition the SCC treated various "constitutional declarations" of the military as binding commands of a "constitutional lawgiver" which pre-empted the commands of all inferior lawgivers, including the military, when acting as a legislator. This hierarchical conception of law as a series of commands issuing from a hierarchy of superior and inferior lawgivers means that legality is determined solely by reference to a particular law's place in this hierarchy, without regard to the content of the command. In this conception of law, there is no place for constitutional silence inasmuch as the legislature and courts are seen simply as carrying out instructions of the constitutional lawgiver. The denial of constitutional silence in turns leads to judicial rhetoric that overdetermines the outcome of particular cases, and fails to tie outcomes of cases to any shared conception of legality between the sovereign and the citizens. This approach to deciding cases negates the possibility that "silence" may be filled by other lawgivers through a deliberative political process. By refusing to accept a place for constitutional silence, the SCC's jurisprudence enshrines a kind of "constitutional despotism" which exacerbates constitutional conflict, rather than mitigating it, by creating incentives for constitutional drafters to write ever more specific constitutional rules to enshrine particular outcomes rather than creating a framework for shared governance.

Keywords: constitutionalism, constitutional silence, constitutional crisis, Egypt, revolution, despotism, authoritarianism, legal positivism, legal realism, liberalism, democracy, Islam

Suggested Citation

Fadel, Mohammad, The Sounds of Silence: The Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt, Constitutional Crisis, and Constitutional Silence (July 1, 2018). Forthcoming in the International Journal of Constitutional Law's upcoming special issue on "Constitutional Silence.", Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3210661

Mohammad Fadel (Contact Author)

University of Toronto - Faculty of Law ( email )

78 and 84 Queen's Park
Toronto, Ontario M5S 2C5
Canada

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
88
Abstract Views
627
rank
323,048
PlumX Metrics