Relational Accommodation in Negotiation: Effects of Egalitarianism and Gender on Economic Efficiency and Relational Capital (Formerly the O. Henry Effect: The Impact of Relational Norms on Negotiation Outcomes)
45 Pages Posted: 15 Sep 2004
Abstract
Highly relational contexts can have costs as well as benefits. Researchers theorize that negotiating dyads in which both parties hold highly relational goals or views of themselves are prone to relational accommodation, a dynamic resulting in inefficient economic outcomes yet high levels of relational capital. Previous research has provided only indirect empirical support for this theory. The present study fills this gap by demonstrating the divergent effects of egalitarianism on economic efficiency and relational capital in negotiation. Dyads engaged in a simulated employment negotiation among strangers within a company that was described as either egalitarian or hierarchical. As hypothesized, dyads assigned to the egalitarian condition reached less efficient economic outcomes yet had higher relational capital than dyads assigned to the hierarchical condition. Negotiations occurring between females resulted in lower joint economic outcomes than negotiations occurring between males. Results are consistent with the theory of relational self construal in negotiation.
Keywords: Negotiation, egalitarianism, hierarchy, power distance, gender, relational self-construal, relational satisficing, organizational culture, relational capital, economic outcomes, joint value, O. Henry Effect
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
What Do People Value When They Negotiate? Mapping the Domain of Subjective Value in Negotiation
By Jared R. Curhan, Hillary Anger Elfenbein, ...
-
By Steven Mestdagh and Marc Buelens
-
Are Some Negotiators Better than Others? Individual Differences in Bargaining Outcomes
By Hillary Anger Elfenbein, Jared R. Curhan, ...
-
By Emily T. Amanatullah, Michael Morris, ...
-
Good Karma: How Individuals Construct Schemas of Reputation in Negotiation Contexts
By Nathan Goates, Bruce Barry, ...
-
By Jared R. Curhan, Hillary Anger Elfenbein, ...
-
The Objective Value of Subjective Value: A Multi-round Negotiation Study
By Jared R. Curhan, Hillary Anger Elfenbein, ...
-
Negotiator Satisfaction in Face-to-Face and Electronically Mediated Negotiations
-
The Polarizing Effect of Arousal on Negotiation
By Ashley D. Brown and Jared R. Curhan