Harm, Sex, and Consequences

54 Pages Posted: 9 Aug 2018 Last revised: 27 Aug 2018

See all articles by I. India Thusi

I. India Thusi

California Western School of Law

Date Written: July 24, 2018

Abstract

At a moment in history when this country incarcerates far too many people, criminal legal theory should set forth a framework for re-examining the current logic of the criminal legal system. This Article is the first to argue that “distributive consequentialism,” which centers the experiences of directly-impacted communities, can address the harms of mass incarceration and mass criminalization. Distributive consequentialism is a framework for assessing whether criminalization is justified. It focuses on the outcomes of criminalization rather than relying on indeterminate moral judgments about blameworthiness, or “desert,” which are often infected by the judgers’ own implicit biases. Distributive consequentialism allows for consideration of both the harms of the conduct and the harms of criminalization itself. It brings an intersectional approach to criminal legal theory by examining the distribution of harm, centering the experience of populations that face intersectional forms of subordination, and viewing the criminal legal system suspiciously. This Article adopts a distributive consequentialist analysis to examine the continued criminalization of sex work as just one example of how the theory can be applied. This application demonstrates how engaging in a distributive consequentialist analysis is a step toward reigning in a system that seems to be ever-expanding, and reframing a criminal legal theory that has grown ambivalent about this expansion.

Keywords: criminal law, criminal procedure, criminology, criminal justice, criminal justice reform, race, overcriminalization, mass incarceration, legal theory, theories of punishment, criminal legal theory, sex work, prostitution

JEL Classification: J21, J7, J48, J46, K13, K14, K42, Z1, Z18

Suggested Citation

Thusi, I. India, Harm, Sex, and Consequences (July 24, 2018). Utah Law Review, Forthcoming; California Western School of Law Research Paper No. 18-11. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3219119

I. India Thusi (Contact Author)

California Western School of Law ( email )

225 Cedar Street
San Diego, CA 92101
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
57
Abstract Views
468
rank
361,214
PlumX Metrics