The Pope and the Capital Juror

Yale Law Journal Forum (Forthcoming)

8 Pages Posted: 2 Oct 2018  

Aliza Cover

University of Idaho College of Law

Date Written: September 16, 2018

Abstract

Counterintuitively, the Pope’s recent announcement that the death penalty is impermissible in all circumstances may make death sentences easier to come by, at least in the short term. The reason for this peculiarity is the “death qualification” of capital jurors – the process of questioning prospective jurors about their views on the death penalty and removing for cause those who are “substantially impaired” in their willingness to consider imposing a death verdict. This Essay anticipates three problematic consequences of the Pope’s declaration, given a capital punishment system that relies on death-qualified juries. First, prosecutors will likely be able to strike a greater number of death-averse jurors, thereby seating juries tilted in favor of death and obtaining death verdicts with greater ease. Second, with more believing Catholics excluded from jury service, the representativeness – and hence the legitimacy – of capital juries will suffer. Third, if the number of death verdicts rises with the ease of disqualification, one of the key “objective indicators” of “evolving standards of decency” will be skewed, registering more support for the death penalty despite – indeed, because of – societal movement against it. The potential for these unexpected consequences to flow from a major pronouncement against the death penalty highlights how death qualification shapes and distorts the practice of capital punishment in our country.

Keywords: death penalty, capital punishment, Eighth Amendment, law and religion, criminal law, sentencing, juries, constitutional law, fair cross-section

Suggested Citation

Cover, Aliza, The Pope and the Capital Juror (September 16, 2018). Yale Law Journal Forum (Forthcoming). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3250429

Aliza Cover (Contact Author)

University of Idaho College of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 442321
Moscow, ID 83844-2321
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
28
Abstract Views
183
PlumX