Traumatic Brain Injury and a Divergence between Moral and Criminal Responsibility

22 Pages Posted: 7 Dec 2018

See all articles by Paul Litton

Paul Litton

University of Missouri School of Law

Date Written: January 21, 2018

Abstract

Traumatic brain injury (TBI), particularly in severe cases, can have extraordinary effects on one’s psychological capacities and, accordingly, may be relevant to several kinds of legal claims in criminal proceedings. The focus of this essay is on claims related to an agent’s status as a responsible agent. How does, or how might, a TBI affect one’s status as a responsible agent? One aim of this essay is to examine multiple ways in which one might think a TBI can affect an agent’s status as an agent who may fairly be held responsible.

However, this essay’s primary goal is to argue that reflection on TBI cases reveals at least some divergence between the criteria for moral responsibility and those for criminal responsibility. Literature on criminal law often assumes that the criteria for legal responsibility mimic the criteria for moral responsibility; however, reflection on TBI cases reveals that those criteria are not coextensive. In short, there may be cases for which ordinary moral intuitions would permit an excuse although the law does not, and should not, recognize. Those cases are ones in which a severe brain injury causes a significant personality change, though does not cause rationality impairments serious enough to undermine legal responsibility. This divergence in responsibility criteria is rooted in the differences between the interpersonal significance of moral blame and the societal purposes of criminal liability.

Suggested Citation

Litton, Paul, Traumatic Brain Injury and a Divergence between Moral and Criminal Responsibility (January 21, 2018). 56 Duq. L. Rev. 35 (2018) (symposium); University of Missouri School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2018-35. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3288747

Paul Litton (Contact Author)

University of Missouri School of Law ( email )

Missouri Avenue & Conley Avenue
Columbia, MO MO 65211
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
52
rank
368,999
Abstract Views
220
PlumX Metrics